Actions Broadly Supportive of Employer-Based Models; Compliance Concerns and Considerations Raised for Wage Deductions, Debiting and Other Practices
DailyPay enters 2021 as the recognized gold standard on-demand pay provider (also known as earned wage access or “EWA”), with the best business model in the industry for both employees and employers. DailyPay has pioneered and championed its award-winning employer-based, non-recourse approach favored by America’s most forward-thinking blue-chip companies. The DailyPay program is uniquely consistent and compliant in all 50 states, which is especially important for enterprise organizations operating across state lines.
On-demand pay shifted from a “nice to have” benefit to an essential one in 2020. Over one-third of employed Americans (36%) are currently relying on their employer for financial assistance programs (Harris Poll). As such, on-demand pay has exploded in adoption, rapidly becoming the way Americans prefer to get paid. In fact, a recent study showed one in six job seekers are looking for an employer that offers on-demand pay.
As the on-demand pay industry continues to evolve and expand, federal regulatory guidance from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has emerged. And this is great news for DailyPay, whose approach to the market, an employer-based, low-cost, non-recourse platform, has been validated by the CFPB. It’s bad news for those in the industry whose model includes employee account debiting, and it includes a variety of considerations, concerns and restrictions impacting vendors of wage deduction programs and their employer clients.
On December 30, 2020, the CFPB issued a follow-up order in response to its November 30, 2020 advisory opinion, which provides guidance on certain EWA programs.
Three important takeaways from the December CFPB EWA order include the following:
- Utilizing debiting as a form of EWA payback may be considered an extension of credit and is excluded from the CFPB order’s safe harbor. Debiting consumer bank accounts continues to be a dangerous and strongly disfavored practice, both by the CFPB and other state authorities, and debiting is a common practice in “credit transactions.”
- Wage deductions continue to be illegal in many states and employers using a wage-deduction model have to contend with additional compliance obligations and restrictions, including employer auditing, reporting, manual payroll deduction processes, and other obligations for deduction programs in the opinion and order.
- Safe harbor determinations do not protect vendors and employers equally. For example, the safe harbor in the December 30 order gives a vendor credit safe harbor coverage, but does not provide employers any safe harbor against state wage and hour wage deduction restrictions, and may specifically burden employers working with certain vendors.
“From day one, DailyPay has intentionally never required any form of employee payback, debiting or payroll deduction that would implicate the extension of credit,” said Jason Lee, CEO and co-founder, DailyPay. “The primary aim of an on-demand pay program should be to enhance the financial stability of employees. Debiting puts employees at risk for surprise overdraft fees or insufficient funds charges, which runs counter to this mission. Further, wage deductions for EWA continue to be prohibited at the state level in many states. We are pleased to see that the CFPB has not endorsed these practices as a means of repayment, and look forward to continuing to provide hard-working Americans with their already earned pay in a consistent, compliant manner.”
HR Technology News: HR Should Focus More On Talent Experience To Engage And Retain Employees