The rise of AI-powered application tools has led to an unprecedented surge in job applications. And while the quantity of applicants has increased, the quality of candidates has not. This flood of applications creates a paradox: while job seekers feel they’re increasing their chances, they’re actually diluting the applicant pool with generic submissions.

For HR professionals, this means navigating through a sea of irrelevant applications. Tightening the selection criteria is a time saver, but what should they optimize for? Studies show that experience is not always the best indicator of performance success. 

The risk in introducing more automated screening lies in missing out on those candidates who could potentially be valuable hires, particularly non-traditional candidates. And this is to say nothing of the documented biases in AI recruitment tools. No wonder 70% of HR professionals are worried about AI in HR. 

Read More on Hrtech : HRTech Interview with Gershon Goren, Founder and CEO at Cangrade  

The stakes are high, especially with the average cost of hiring a new employee clocking in upwards of $5,000 – and some estimates reaching much higher. 

HR professionals are best poised to stop this trend in its tracks by ensuring the human touch is felt at all stages of the hiring process and finding ways to leverage AI properly to save valuable time without compromising on filling roles with qualified candidates.

Identify The Limits of AI in Assessing Potential

While AI excels at processing vast amounts of data and identifying patterns, it struggles with predicting a candidate’s potential for growth, adaptability and cultural fit – qualities that significantly impact long-term success. The framework of employee lifetime value is still developing, but it’s critical to consider that these intangibles of “fit” and contribution should not be relegated to algorithms. 

This highlights a critical limitation of AI in hiring: its inability to fully grasp the nuances of human potential. AI can summarize a candidate’s past achievements, but it can’t truly understand how someone might lead a team through a challenging project, collaborate on an innovative solution or inspire colleagues during tough times. 

The most effective hiring strategies will leverage AI as a powerful tool to enhance human decision-making, not replace it. AI can handle the operational side with ease: scheduling, communication and even feedback. This frees up HR professionals to focus on what truly matters: engaging with candidates, understanding their unique value propositions and evaluating how their skills and experiences might contribute to and evolve within the company.

For instance, AI could be used to create comprehensive skill profiles based on a candidate’s application, work samples and assessment results. HR professionals can then use these profiles as a starting point for in-depth conversations about how the candidate’s skills might be applied to current challenges and future projects within the organization. 

This dovetails with the increased focus and state-level government support shift towards more skills-based hiring. AI can play a crucial role here, helping to identify and match specific skills to job requirements. However, the nuanced evaluation of how these skills might apply in unique organizational contexts remains a distinctly human task.

Consider a candidate transitioning from event planning to project management in tech. An AI with strict parameters on years of relevant experience might flag this as a mismatch, but a human recruiter can recognize how skills in coordinating complex events translate directly to managing intricate tech projects. This human insight is crucial for identifying adaptable talent that can drive innovation and growth.

AI’s potential: Assessments, Interviews and Authenticity 

In a world of keyword-optimized resumes and generic cover letters, three areas stand out with their potential for both AI disruption and continued human-in-the-loop contributions: assessments, interviews and authenticity.  

When we say assessments, we don’t mean the two-hour psychometric tests that candidates dread. There is increasingly interesting research into assessing soft skills in meaningful ways, with some companies even employing virtual or augmented reality to simulate scenarios in which candidates can be evaluated on applied skills. This can extend to upskilling and reskilling of employees through agent-based simulations. The interview process is also seeing new technologies entering the space, whether it’s with video pre-interviews or interviews with skills-based frameworks and transcription reports.

The question, of course, is how much potential can we quantify with skills taxonomies? What lies beyond the reach of the algorithm to measure when it comes to human behavior? AI is only as good as the data that it is built upon. Person-to-person interactions in the workplace, like team building and in people management, do not lend themselves to that kind of granular data.

The gap between what we can track and predict in those data points is precisely the gap where humans can and must be kept in the loop.

Ultimately, the future of hiring lies in striking the right balance between technological efficiency and human insight. AI will undoubtedly continue to evolve, offering increasingly sophisticated tools for candidate sourcing, skill assessment and preliminary screening. However, the final decisions – the ones that shape company culture, drive innovation and determine long-term success – will remain in human hands.

HR professionals need to be adept at leveraging AI tools while honing their uniquely human skills: emotional intelligence, context interpretation and the ability to envision how a candidate’s skills might evolve to meet future organizational needs.

In the end, hiring is about more than matching skills to job descriptions – it’s about finding individuals who can adapt, grow and contribute to an organization’s future in ways that may not be immediately apparent. By maintaining a human-centric approach enhanced by AI, companies are more likely to build diverse, skilled teams capable of driving innovation and adapting to future challenges – all while minimizing inefficiencies in the hiring process. 

As we navigate this new era of AI-assisted hiring, it is crucial to remember that the most powerful tool in our arsenal remains our human ability to connect, understand and envision potential. This is how businesses can build workforces that are not just skilled, but truly transformative.

Catch more HRTech Insights: HRTech Interview with JD Dillon, Chief Learning Officer at Axonify

[To share your insights with us, please write to psen@itechseries.com ]

More Insights from the HRTech Talk Podcast By HRTech Series

HRTech Talk by HRTech Series Featuring Inclusively